Theodore Roosevelt: The Making of a Progressive Reformer
by Kathleen Dalton
Theodore Roosevelt’s interesting life often tempts biographers
to write about him with the history left out. His story offers plenty
of drama. Born in 1858 to a wealthy family in New York City he waged a
life and death struggle against childhood asthma. Books about brave warriors
and explorers comforted the boy when he was sick. His father, Theodore
Senior, believed that nature and outdoor exercise could build boys’
bodies and characters, and he put pressure on his son to throw off his
invalidism by embracing exercise. In his teens, young Theodore rose to
his father’s challenge and strengthened his body by exercising and
going hunting. He remained a forever-restless seeker after adventure and
knowledge, a man who embraced many identities in his life: hunter, cowboy,
writer, scientist, historian, explorer, reformer, politician, and, finally,
president.
Roosevelt, or T.R. as he was known, invented the modern presidency. A
man full of contradictions, he fought bravely in the Spanish-American
War, but also proved himself a presidential peacemaker who averted wars
by the skillful use of diplomacy and so won the Nobel Peace Prize. In
retrospect, T.R. stands out as a unique American wonder, like Niagara
Falls. But his story is larger than a one-of-a-kind personal journey from
weakness to strength and accomplishment.
In fact, the broad scope of T.R.’s large life gives us clues about
the grand historical dramas and conflicts of the era between the Civil
War and World War I. In the decades after 1865 the US economy boomed.
Railroads paved the way toward new national opportunities to trade and
provided a business model for the rise of the modern corporation. Linking
the new industrial cities and stimulating modern systems of banking and
manufacturing, railroads also led the way toward the business consolidations
in the form of mergers and monopolies. Wealthy Americans who invested
wisely in factories and railroads grew richer than ever, while industrial
workers and new immigrants struggled to survive, flocking to crowded cities
where they competed for difficult jobs. American cities were plagued by
dirt, chaos, and crime as their streets were ripped up to make way for
new sites of manufacturing and trade. By 1890 the census showed that 9%
of the population controlled 71% of the wealth, and by 1900, about three
quarters of the American people qualified as poor. No wonder that populists,
labor leaders, and socialists of many ideological stripes railed against
the trusts and the problem of inequality.
As a boy in New York, T.R. grew up among the wealthiest and most exclusive
segment of society. Despite his advantages he found urban life in the
Gilded Age repellent and confining. Four years after he graduated from
Harvard in 1880, T.R. went west searching for a new life free of the constraints
of the industrializing east. He bought two ranches in the Dakota Territory
and lived the life of a cowboy. His restlessness and his time as a cowpuncher
belong to a historical moment after the Civil War when urban life felt
hopelessly blighted and the tide of westward migration provoked the Sioux
Wars and the killing of many Plains natives. Custer’s demise at
the Battle of Little Big Horn invited more vicious reprisals, and along
with the military suppression of native people came the dominance of western
settlements by railroads and mining corporations. Nevertheless, the West
and the cowboy remained powerful symbols of freedom to T.R. and many men
of his generation who dreamed of living unshackled by the restrictions
of modern desk jobs and polite Eastern society. On his Dakota ranches,
T.R.’s cattle froze to death and he failed to turn a profit, but
he wrote articles and then books for eastern audiences about the hazards
and romance of his ranch life. In Hunting Trips of a Ranchman
(1885), Ranch Life and the Hunting Trail (1888), Thomas Hart
Benton (1887), The Wilderness Hunter (1893), and The
Winning of the West (1889-1896), T.R. argued that the essence of
being an American was having a fierce frontier spirit. He sought to kindle
across class and regional lines a strong spirit of national renewal. By
the 1890s, Roosevelt found literary celebrity among a vast readership
of eastern urbanites longing for visions of escape and adventure.
As American cities mushroomed in the 1880s and 1890s, political parties
dominated by bosses and supported by immigrant voters offended reformers
of T.R.’s privileged class. He believed that garbage pickup, clean
water, safe bridges, public transportation, and sewers were investments
that city governments needed to make to promote public health and to facilitate
economic development. Boss-run cities were slow to respond to such urban
problems. Even before his western interlude T.R. as a New York State assemblyman
had proven he was a precocious reformer who knew how to work with the
regular Republican party. He went after a corrupt judge and tried hard
to reform the conditions of immigrant labor in tenements. When Roosevelt
returned to New York in 1886, it was in the role of urban reformer at
a time when corrupt party bosses won elections in part to give their followers
jobs and collect political assessments from officeholders. T.R. believed
that party hacks should not get government jobs; instead he wanted hiring
to be based on civil service exams to raise the level of literacy and
competence of government workers. Because of T.R.’s role in the
emerging Civil Service reform movement President Benjamin Harrison appointed
him a federal Civil Service Commissioner in 1889. In this role, he and
other reformers expanded the number of jobs filled by exam rather than
by party loyalty.
Shocked by reports that party bosses and the police were in cahoots with
saloons and prostitution rings, New York City reformers formed new alliances
in the early 1890s. Though women could not yet vote in New York, they
joined reform groups such as the Woman’s Municipal League of New
York and various good government groups to elect William Lafayette Strong,
a reform mayor, in 1894. Mayor Strong brought T.R. back to New York as
a police commissioner, where he worked to clean up the police department.
T.R. soon pushed the Police Chief out of the department after discovering
that the he had accepted bribes at the same time he charged brothels and
saloons protection money. T.R. also expanded and professionalized the
police by giving his cops telephones, bicycles, fingerprinting, and photographic
rogues’ galleries. In addition to his belief in law and order, T.R.
wrote articles advocating laws to regulate housing to make it safer and
more affordable, and called for rapid transit and parks for city-dwellers.
After serving as Assistant Secretary of the Navy and lobbying for American
expansion and the Spanish-American War, T.R. ran for Governor of New York
in 1899. Heeding the serious challenge that Democrat William Jennings
Bryan had made to William McKinley in 1896 by railing against trusts,
monopolies, and railroads, T.R. as governor won the passage of new factory-inspection
and tenement house laws. T.R. believed that he had not gone far enough
as a reformer, but his gubernatorial career was cut short in 1900 when
New York’s Republican boss, Boss Platt pushed T.R. out of New York
by arranging for him to become President McKinley’s Vice Presidential
running mate. Then the vice presidency was seen as a dead end job rather
than a political stepping stone. The McKinley-Roosevelt ticket won the
election, but in 1901, an anarchist assassinated President McKinley and
T.R. ascended to the presidency.
As President, Theodore Roosevelt had to deal with the dominant conservative
wing of his party and a Congress hostile to reform. He took the reins
of the presidency without much more of a plan than to emulate Abraham
Lincoln’s wisdom and his ability to unite the nation. But legislation
required the cooperation of Congress—and it was not readily won.
T.R.’s legislative victories were modest but historic—a railroad
regulation bill, a Meat Inspection Act, and a Pure Food and Drug Act which
established federal responsibility for inspecting products to protect
consumers. Roosevelt had better success using his presidency as a “bully
pulpit,” popularizing reform ideas among voters. He convinced a
generation of Americans that government should be responsive to injustice.
When he grew impatient with the executive-legislative give-and-take, he
took bold executive action that did not require legislative cooperation.
Most notably, he instructed his Justice Department to prosecute the Northern
Securities holding company, charging it with monopolistic practices. He
won the case when it came before the Supreme Court, earning the moniker
of trust buster. He also made labor history. Although previous strikes
had usually prompted presidents to side with management by sending federal
troops to suppress strikers, in the Anthracite Coal Strike T.R. pressed
management to negotiate with labor. He also used executive orders to protect
forests, wildlife, the Grand Canyon, and other natural wonders and historic
sites, thereby cementing his reputation as America’s greatest conservationist
president.
T.R.’s evolution as a reformer did not end when he left the presidency
in 1909, for he had been swept up in a tidal wave of progressive reform
ideas. Influenced by a large network of women reformers, including settlement
house founder Jane Addams, the Consumer League’s feisty Florence
Kelley, and activists in the Women’s Trade Union League, T.R. endorsed
state minimum wage laws and mother’s pensions (later Aid to Families
with Dependent Children). When he ran for president in 1912 on the third
party Bull Moose ticket he endorsed woman suffrage and the modern welfare
state, i.e. unemployment, health, and old age insurance. Though he never
returned to the White House, T.R. made his mark as an environmental and
urban reformer, a man who reflected his times and their debates, but also
a man who tried to face the future by promoting new causes. T.R.’s
story then is not just a private tale of growth and change. Roosevelt
the reformer remains one of the most fascinating personalities in American
history.
Kathleen Dalton is Cecil F. P. Bancroft Instructor of History and
Social Science and Co-director of the Brace Center for Gender Studies
at Phillips Academy in Andover, Massachusetts. She is an External Fellow
at the International History Institute at Boston University and the author
of Theodore Roosevelt: A Strenuous Life.
|