Schuyler, Philip John, 1733-1804 to James Duane

Written by Major General Schuyler to Duane as a New York delegate to the Continental Congress. References Duane's letter that was delivered 26 November. Says he had to abandon the fortress on York Island because the enemy's strength was overwhelming. Defends his actions as the best he could have done in the situation confronting him. Compares himself favorably to Washington's defeat in New York in August 1776 saying "I wish Gen: Washington had adhered to his own opinion and rejected the Intemporate advice of people of more prowess than Wisdom. In such a situation of ours It is now Eligible slowly to follow Fabius." Schuyler is recommending avoiding combat to preserve the army, a strategy that Washington would adopt. Gives intelligence of three counties that wish to break away from New York. These counties comprise what would become Vermont. Says they should not be allowed to break away asking "would it be amiss If Every state had It In their power to Call for the aid of such troops as they might warrant of any raised therein for the purpose of quelling Internal disorders." Wants to go to Philadelphia, but if Duane, Livingston, or Jay don't go, he will delay his trip a few days. Asks his compliments be sent to Livingston and Jay. Says General Horatio Gates has brought trouble on himself in New Jersey by getting involved in internal squabbles.